Judith Timms OBE, NYAS Founder and Trustee reflects on the history and impact of children’s rights.

35 years ago, two eagerly anticipated events changed the landscape of children’s rights. The first, on 14 October 1991, was the long-awaited implementation of the Children Act 1989 (CA 1989) and the second, on 15 December the same year, was the UK Government’s ratification of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC). Taken together, they represented a sea change in how society expects its children and young people to be treated, both by their parents and by the state. From this distance it is hard to appreciate the excitement preceding these events. 50,000 family justice professionals attended training sessions on the provisions of the new Act.

Although not (and regrettably still not) directly incorporated into English domestic legislation, UNCRC acted as a catalyst for change and this was reflected in the thinking that shaped the CA1989 and led to it being hailed as a Charter for Children. The 54 articles contained in the UNCRC can be broken down into three main categories: provision, protection and participation. Together these provide a checklist of internationally acceptable minimum standards against which the conduct and public policies of Governments may be measured and, if necessary, challenged. The Convention achieved a remarkable degree of international consensus and has now been ratified by 196 countries. In essence, it is a blueprint for the welfare of the world’s children.

Public concern about looked after children had escalated following the Enquiries into the deaths in care of Maria Colwell (1974), Jasmine Beckford (1985), Heidi Koseida (1986) and Kimberley Carlyle (1987). The Report of the Enquiry into Child Abuse in Cleveland was published in 1987 amidst a media frenzy which implied that once again social workers had got it wrong. Years of practitioners asking parliament to overhaul the existing patchwork of childcare law resulted in an Act which is still regarded with international respect.

CA1989 amalgamated public and private law and for the first time gave paramount consideration to the welfare of the child. Section 1 set out a detailed welfare checklist that included a duty to consider the ascertainable wishes and feelings of children in the light of their age and understanding and a duty to consider children’s race, ethnicity, culture and religion. The new provisions put children centre stage and reflected the requirements of Article 12 UNCRC, which gives children a right to be heard and represented when courts and public bodies make far-reaching decisions about their lives.

CA 1989 changed how local authority children’s services operate. The concept of parents’ rights was replaced by one of children’s rights and parents’ responsibilities. Courts had to avoid delay wherever possible and the principal of minimum intervention required them not to make orders unless this would be better for the child than no order at all. Local authorities were required to work in partnership with parents.

The statutory powers and duties of Guardians ad Litem were considerably enhanced and expanded, enabling them to work alongside solicitors in a ‘tandem model’ of independent representation of children in a wide range of care and related proceedings. The ‘tandem model’ represents a working synthesis of children’s rights and children’s welfare and it is a powerful combination for children. Local authorities were unused to their definitions of the 'best interests of children' in their care being challenged and many were initially highly resistant to the idea of Guardians ad Litem having additional powers to scrutinize their records and cross-examine social workers in court. But the key role that guardians were to play in listening to and amplifying the voice of the child was seen as 'the lynch pin to the successful implementation of the Act'. The crucial importance of the Guardian’s role was (and still is) in making an independent judgement between the potentially conflicting demands of children’s rights, children’s rescue, the autonomy of the family and the duty of the state. Getting that balance right in relation to each child remains at the core of the state’s statutory duties.

What practical difference did the Act make for looked after children? Take the example of a frightened and lonely child who has just been removed from an abusive home and placed in residential care miles away from friends, family, school and everything that was familiar to them. In 1990 - pre CA1989 and pre mobile phones - they had no access to or right to make telephone calls. They had no access to any means of complaint apart from to the local authority social worker who had placed them there. The role of their Guardian ad Litem has ceased at the conclusion of the court proceedings. They had no idea if or when there would be a review of their cases. They had no information about what had happened to their parents or siblings or when they would see them again. They had been told that it is an offence to run away from the home they are in and they are effectively cut off from the outside world in what may itself be an abusive regime. They were essentially powerless.

In the same situation in 1992, that child had the right to access a phone and to make a complaint or representation about their care under Section 26 CA1989. If they were lucky, they might have been included in a NYAS pilot scheme which introduced independent advocacy to all NCH (now Action for Children) children’s homes in the North of England, in the run-up to implementation of the new legislation. If so, they would have been given the NYAS Helpline number and access to an independent advocate who would visit them in their children’s home and stand beside them, giving them a voice and making sure their complaints were heard. That pilot scheme was the starting point for the establishment of NYAS's extensive network of Independent Advocates and Independent Visitors who operate across England and Wales today. Many thousands of children have accessed help via the hotline and benefited from NYAS advocacy services in the last 35 years.

The new provisions were not implemented without resistance. Some practitioners thought that telling children that they could complain was like handing them a lighted firework and that children’s services would be overwhelmed with complaints - a sad indictment of their confidence in existing safeguards.

The first time NYAS included a care experienced young person as a speaker at one of its conferences, several local authority social workers in the audience walked out, saying that it was ‘unprofessional’ to have young people there pointing out failures in the care system.

Regrettably, the full potential of CA1989 provisions to support children and families has never been fully exploited, largely due to lack of resources. One of the most significant changes and one which should have had far reaching implications, was the provision in Section10.8, which gave children the right to seek leave to initiate proceedings themselves by applying directly to court However, experience in the last 35 years shows that it is virtually impossible for children to initiate their own proceedings. First, they are dependent on the good offices of adults to give them the necessary information and tell them they have the right to do so. Secondly, they need to find a solicitor who judges them competent to give instructions and willing to represent them in court. This provision continues to be consistently ignored and has fallen into abeyance, which is a matter of great regret given that the architects of CA1989 were seeking to build in safeguards and to reflect Article 12 UNCRC in recognizing children as the bearers of independent rights with their own perspective. A large body of evidence from research and practice supports the view that outcomes for children and young people are better when they have been given accurate information about the options available to them and properly consulted about the plans for the lives they will be required to live.      

The essential weakness in implementing Children's UNCRC rights is that they are dependent on the goodwill of adults to enforce them and so are particularly fragile. They make adults uneasy because they threaten their ability to make unchallenged decisions. This has meant that children’s rights have been consistently diluted by being filtered through the well-meaning but essentially subjective lens of the adult view of the child’s ‘best interests’.

Any parent will tell you that there is no formula or course of action which can guarantee a child’s best interest. There is no science of parenting and individual judgments can be subjective. CA1989 and UNCRC have provided a forensic framework for the development of children’s rights-based services which incorporate principles of rights, participation and consultation. Best practice, therefore, is that which incorporates a core curriculum of rights within definitions of welfare at every stage of decision making, both in and out of court. We still have a way to go.

 In the words of Professor Michael Freeman: ‘The framework for children’s rights is very different from those of welfare which provides protection and is essentially paternalistic. A children’s rights framework sees children as active participants in social processes. Rights are valuable commodities, important moral coinage. They enable us to stand with dignity to demand our due without having to grovel plead or beg. A world with claim rights is one in which all people are dignified objects of respect. Love compassion, having the child’s best interests in mind are important values but they are no substitute for rights’.

JUDITH TIMMS OBE
NYAS FOUNDER AND TRUSTEE